Most adults make their own decisions about medical treatment. But what happens if an accident, illness or another circumstance means you cannot make a particular treatment decision yourself?
Victorian law provides a framework for determining who can make that decision. A medical treatment decision maker in Victoria may have authority to make medical treatment decisions when a person does not have decision-making capacity for a particular decision.
Importantly, capacity is considered in relation to the decision being made. A person may be capable of making some decisions even if they cannot make others.
Understanding these rules can help you plan and clarify who should act if you are unable to make a future medical treatment decision.
What Does Losing Decision-Making Capacity Mean?
A person’s age, illness or disability does not automatically mean they lack decision-making capacity.
For a particular decision, capacity generally involves being able to understand the relevant information, retain it long enough to make the decision, use or weigh that information and communicate the decision in some way.
This distinction matters because substitute decision-making should not replace a person’s own decision where they still have capacity to make it.
Example: A Temporary Loss of Capacity
Imagine someone is unconscious after a serious accident and a medical treatment decision needs to be made.
While unconscious, that person cannot make the particular decision themselves. Depending on the circumstances, the appropriate medical treatment decision maker may need to act.
If the person later recovers and has capacity to make their own treatment decisions, they can resume making those decisions themselves.
Who Can Be Your Medical Treatment Decision Maker in Victoria?
An adult with decision-making capacity can formally appoint someone to make medical treatment decisions if they later lose capacity.
But what happens if no appointment has been made?
Victorian law uses a hierarchy to identify the first person who is reasonably available, willing and able to make the decision.
Depending on the circumstances, this may be:
- A medical treatment decision maker formally appointed by the person.
- A guardian appointed by VCAT who has authority to make medical treatment decisions.
- A person with a close and continuing relationship with the individual, following the order established under Victorian law.
That order can include a spouse or domestic partner, primary carer, adult child, parent or adult sibling.
Additional rules can apply where more than one relative falls within the same level of the hierarchy.
Does Your Closest Family Member Automatically Make the Decision?
Not necessarily.
Being someone’s spouse, child or parent does not automatically mean you will have first authority to make their medical treatment decisions.
For example, if the person has formally appointed someone as their medical treatment decision maker, that appointment takes priority within the relevant hierarchy. A VCAT-appointed guardian with appropriate authority may also take priority over family members.
Understanding the medical treatment laws in Victoria can therefore help families determine who is legally authorised to act rather than relying on assumptions.
Choosing a Decision Maker Before You Lose Capacity
Planning allows you to choose someone you trust instead of relying solely on the default legal hierarchy.
You may also consider making an advance care directive. This can be used to record certain instructions about medical treatment and/or your values and preferences.
Having these arrangements in place can provide useful guidance if you later cannot make a particular medical treatment decision yourself.
VK Lawyers’ medical treatment and decision-making lawyers in Victoria can assist with understanding the legal options available for planning.
Want to Plan Ahead? Get advice about documenting your wishes and future medical decision-making arrangements.
How Should a Medical Treatment Decision Maker Make a Decision?
A medical treatment decision maker does not simply choose the treatment they personally prefer.
The decision-making process focuses on the decision the person themselves would have made if they had capacity.
This can involve considering any applicable instructional directive, a relevant values directive, preferences the person previously expressed and their values.
Example: The Decision Maker Has a Different View
Suppose someone has discussed their treatment preferences with their appointed decision maker and has also recorded relevant values in an advance care directive.
Later, the person loses decision-making capacity.
The decision maker may personally prefer a different treatment. However, their own preference is not the central consideration. The person’s directions, preferences and values are important to the decision being made on their behalf.
This is a key feature of substitute decision-making in the medical treatment context.
Consent to Medical Treatment Law in Victoria
A person with decision-making capacity generally makes their own decision about whether to consent to or refuse medical treatment.
Where the person lacks capacity for the particular decision, the relevant medical treatment decision maker may need to decide on their behalf, subject to applicable legal requirements and any valid instructional directive.
An advance care directive may contain an instructional directive dealing with consent to or refusal of particular medical treatment.
Victoria’s laws governing consent to medical treatment should therefore be considered alongside any appointment or advance care directive the person has made.
Guardianship and Administration in Victoria: What Is the Difference?
Guardianship and administration perform different functions.
A guardian appointed by VCAT may have authority over specified personal matters. Depending on the order, this can include authority relevant to medical treatment.
An administrator, by contrast, is generally appointed to make decisions about specified financial and property matters.
This distinction is important when considering guardianship and administration in Victoria. An administrator does not automatically become someone’s medical treatment decision maker because they manage that person’s financial affairs.
Where a guardian has the relevant medical treatment authority, however, they can have a role within the statutory framework for identifying the medical treatment decision maker.
These arrangements may also be relevant to broader estate planning, particularly when preparing for future personal and financial decisions.
Why Planning Ahead Can Matter
Without planning, family members may need to work through the statutory hierarchy to determine who has authority to make a medical treatment decision.
Making an appointment while you have capacity can provide greater clarity about who you want to act.
You may also wish to consider powers of attorney for financial and personal matters. In Victoria, these arrangements are separate from appointing a medical treatment decision maker.
An advance care directive can also provide information about your treatment instructions, preferences and values.
Conclusion
Planning for future medical treatment decisions is about more than choosing someone you trust. It can also help communicate your preferences and clarify who has authority to act if you cannot make a particular decision yourself.
VK Lawyers assists clients with medical treatment decision-making, powers of attorney and related estate planning matters in Victoria. Our team can explain the available arrangements and help you understand how they may apply to your circumstances.
Planning for Future Medical Decisions? Speak with VK Lawyers about documenting your wishes and future decision-making arrangements.
Frequently Asked Questions:
Who can be my medical treatment decision maker in Victoria?
An adult with decision-making capacity can formally appoint an eligible person. If no appointment has been made, Victorian law provides a hierarchy for determining who may make the relevant medical treatment decision.
Does my spouse automatically become my medical treatment decision maker?
Not always. A formally appointed medical treatment decision maker or a VCAT-appointed guardian with relevant authority may take priority under the applicable hierarchy.
What happens if I only temporarily lose decision-making capacity?
A medical treatment decision maker may need to act while you lack capacity for the particular decision. If you regain capacity, you can make your own medical treatment decisions again.
Is a medical treatment decision maker the same as a guardian?
Not necessarily. A medical treatment decision maker is the person authorised to make a relevant medical treatment decision when you lack capacity. A guardian is appointed by VCAT and has the authority specified in the guardianship order. A guardian with relevant medical treatment authority may also be the medical treatment decision maker.
Can I record my medical treatment preferences before losing capacity?
Yes. If you have decision-making capacity, an advance care directive can be used to record certain instructions and/or your values and preferences concerning future medical treatment.
Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Medical treatment and decision-making arrangements depend on individual circumstances, and specific legal advice should be obtained where required.